MPs reject claim Johnson Partygate probe is unfair
MPs investigating if Boris Johnson misled Parliament over Partygate have rejected claims the probe is "unfair".
The Privileges Committee is looking into what the former PM told Parliament about Covid-rule breaking.
Lord Pannick, a lawyer hired by the government to examine the committee's approach, called the investigation "fundamentally flawed".
The committee said Lord Pannick had "a systemic misunderstanding of the parliamentary process".
Mr Johnson could be suspended from Parliament or even lose his seat if the committee rules against him.
The committee is investigating whether he obstructed the Commons by telling it that pandemic rules had been followed during lockdown events in No 10 that since led to Covid fines.
Last month, the committee decided it would not have to prove Mr Johnson deliberately misled MPs to show he committed a "contempt of Parliament" by obstructing its work.
However it will still consider whether Mr Johnson deliberately or knowingly misled the House of Commons.
Mr Johnson could be hauled before the committee in the autumn to account for what he previously told MPs.
In his legal advice, Lord Pannick warned that "the threat of contempt proceedings for unintentional mistakes would have a seriously chilling effect" on MPs.
But the committee rejected this as "wholly misplaced and itself misleading".
Ministers who "inadvertently mislead" MPs are able to correct previous statements under current rules, committee argued.
While foreign secretary, Mr Johnson formally corrected his comments to the House five times.
Ministers are expected to "do so at the earliest opportunity to avoid misleading the House in line with the rules that apply to all MPs", the committee said.
The independent crossbench peer said the committee's approach is inconsistent with past cases where intent was taken into account and the process would be deemed "unlawful" if it was tested in a court.
He criticised the committee for taking evidence anonymously and said Mr Johnson should be told the details of the case against him.
The committee said Lord Pannick's opinion was "founded on a systemic misunderstanding of the parliamentary process and misplaced analogies with the criminal law".
It rejected Lord Pannick's call for Mr Johnson to be represented by a lawyer who would speak on his behalf and cross-examine witnesses.
In a statement the committee, said it "does not have discretion to allow counsel to speak in a hearing and conduct cross-examination, and it would require a decision of the House to permit this".
Parliament voted to launch the inquiry in April, after a series of revelations about events held in and around Downing Street while Covid restrictions were in place.
An official investigation later concluded rules had been broken and a police inquiry led to 83 people, including Mr Johnson himself, being fined.
The former prime minister has admitted that previous statements to Parliament - in which he insisted all rules had been followed - had since been proved incorrect, but he believed them to be true at the time.
He denied deliberately misleading MPs.
-
Sainsbury’s boss: We are not profiting from tall pricesJapanese Moon lander likely to have crashedIs this anti-vaxxer the next Alex Jones?James Corden gets choked up in last Late Late Show songCan you get incostlyer wideband deals with consequentlycial tariffs?Mob burns suspected gang members to death in HaitiLGBT troops take love for Eurovision to front lineUS official warns migrants: 'Border is not open'REVEALED: Convicted felon, 61, arrested for murder of Microconsequentlyft executive Jared Bridegan rented his Jackconsequentlynville home from new husband of victim's EX-WIFE: Cops admit killer 'didn't act alone'Afghan interpreter shot twice denied compensation
Next article:Jill Biden wears sunglasses in first emergeance since cancer surgery on her eye - as husband Joe ref utilizes to answer questions on documents scandal (notwithstanding finding time to emerge in SNL sketch)
- ·Asda buys petrol station grohigh EG for £2.3bn
- ·Alaskan moose visits the cinema... and steals popcorn
- ·Stardust fire inquest of 'paramount importance'
- ·Autopsy shows Tyre Nichols died of blunt force
- ·Loose Women's Denise Welch pays tribute to 'wonderful actress' Josephine Melville, 61, who played Tessa Parker in the 1980s after she died backstage at play
- ·UK citizens tell of attempts to escape Sudan
- ·Man pleads not guilty to shooting teen on doorstep
- ·Man in his 40s dies after County Cavan crash
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Newcastle agree to sign Anthony Gordon for £40m - plus £5m in add-ons - with a medical set for tomorrow after the Everton youth product missed days of training to compel it through
- ·Missing Australian's body found inside crocodile
- ·Sudanese NHS doctor finally allowed to return to UK
- ·Turkish mass arrests in Kurdish areas ahead of vote
- ·Climate activists heckle Ted Cruz on The View: Whoopi Goldberg tells protesters to leave for trying to drown him out during shouting match over Trump, the election and January 6
- ·1,000 days imprisoned in China for an unknown reason
- ·Defector police boss killed by bomb in Ukraine
- ·Did this woman die because her genitals were cut?
- ·'All I expect from this administration is another set of lies': Trump and Cruz lead Republicans blasting Biden after DOJ seizes SIX more classified documents from President's Delaware home
- ·Meeting the would-be queen of Italy
- ·89 rounds fired in Alabama shooting
- ·Uruguay country profile
- ·Patrick Mahomes suffers ankle injury in first quarter of do-or-die playoff game in huge blow for Kansas City Chiefs... but star quarterback returns to lead his team to a HUGE win over the Jaguars
- ·Ukraine sets up positions across river in Kherson
- ·Swiss villagers told to flee monster rockslide
- ·Senegal country profile
- ·Silicon Valley Bank: 500 jobs cut by fresh owner First Citizens
- ·Joe Biden and a life in politics
- ·Flooding: Toilet bungs and other prevention measures to save homes
- ·Alleged Thai serial killer's ex-husband surrenders
- ·Inside hospital where oxygen runs out
- ·Up to 4,000 Britons still stuck in Sudan - minister
- ·Shell AGM: Climate activists storm sharehhistoricer gathering
- ·The homemade submarines smuggling cocaine to Europe
- ·Ulster Bank to close all branches in Republic of Ireland
- ·Jackass star Bam Margera turns himself in to police
- ·Superstar American Coco Gauff is dumped OUT of the Australian Open in the fourth round, as Jelena Ostapenko produces huge straight-sets shock to set up quarter-final clash with Elena Rybakina
- ·Over a barrel: Sudan mediators face tough choices