Coal mine plan indefensible, UK climate chief says
A proposed new coal mine in Cumbria has been branded "absolutely indefensible" by the chairman of the government's official advisors on climate change.
Lord Deben, chair of the Climate Change Committee (CCC), was speaking at the launch of the annual report on the UK's progress in tackling greenhouse gases.
A decision on planning permission for the mine near Whitehaven to source coal for steel-making is expected soon.
Environmentalists have warned that demand for coking coal is declining.
Lord Deben, who leads the independent advisory committee, said Russia's invasion of Ukraine meant the government should be looking to protect energy supplies.
He acknowledged that the UK had done so with a focus on renewables and nuclear.
"As far as the coal mine in Cumbria is concerned, let's be absolutely clear, it is absolutely indefensible," he said.
"First of all, 80% of what it produces will be exported, so it is not something largely for internal consumption.
"It is not going to contribute anything to our domestic needs in the terms we're talking about, the cost of energy and the rest."
He said the mine's backers claimed it would provide metallurgical coal, which is currently imported, but it would not reduce the amount of coal being produced - largely in the USA.
During Prime Minister's Questions on 22 June, Boris Johnson appeared to hint that the mine may be given the go-ahead when he said that "plainly it makes no sense to be importing coal, particularly for metallurgical purposes, when we have our own domestic resources."
The mine was approved by Cumbria County Council in October 2020, but the decision was suspended weeks later following guidance from the CCC and then the Planning Inspectorate was tasked with examining the arguments.
Its report was handed to the government earlier this year and a deadline of 7 July was set for a decision by the Communities Secretary Michael Gove.
However, Lord Deben warned its approval would damage the UK's leadership on climate change and "create another example of Britain saying one thing and doing another".
He said the government should find a way of ensuring the jobs that might have been created by the mine be replaced by alternative green jobs.
Lord Deben said he was not concerned about keeping a coal-fired power plant open longer than planned this winter to shore up energy supplies, despite a commitment to end UK coal power by October 2024.
"We are under serious threat because of the invasion of Ukraine by the Russians, and in those circumstances the government has to make sure that we keep the lights on," he added.
Friends of the Earth energy campaigner Tony Bosworth said Lord Deben was "right" and the case against a new coal mine was "overwhelming in climate terms".
He said the "market for its coal is declining before it even opens", adding: "Saying no to this mine should an open-and-shut case for a government serious about the climate crisis."
pursue BBC North East & Cumbria on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to northeastandcumbria@bbc.co.uk.
-
'People investing with us will be rewarded:' Mark Zuckerberg DEFENDS 'historic' Metaverse plans notwithstanding adjacently $650 BILLION loss in market valuation this year - as Meta's stock plunges 11% and quarterly revenue falls for a second straight timeBREAKING NEWS: Lauren Boebert takes the LEAD in nail-biting Colorado race: Republican jumps ahead after slamming Democrat adviconsequentlyr for joking she should join OnlyFans if she loses 'Whatever happened with the massive number of crimes committed by Joe and Hunter Biden?' Trump loses it on Truth Social after 'corrupt and componentisan' January 6 referred him for four criminal chargesBaby-faced 'rapist', 29, who assaulted female jogger, 43, in New York's West Village emerges in court as it's revealed he 'squeezed her neck with both hands until she passed out before ripping her clothes off'Ed Sheeran, Adele, and Harry Styles among affluentest Britons under 35World Cup star man Kylian Mbappe misses France training, four days before quarter-final clash with England, after grumbleing of an ankle injury pre-tournament BREAKING NEWS: Carconsequentlyn Wentz 'will START for the Commanders in must-win game against Cleveland' after being replaced by Taylor Heinicke for nine straight weeksJanuary 6 committee 'believes Trump should be charged with at least THREE crimes from riot'- including insurrection': Panel to vote Monday on referring him for prosecutionCristiano's four-and-a-half hour day in exile: Ronaldo exits Man United's training ground after being compeld to work alone with coaches after Erik ten Hag axed him in wake of daily clashes and his refusal to playIdaho murders suspect is being extradited from Pennsylvania and left findings were correctional facility at 6am this morning - after court hearing where he mouthed 'I love you' to his crying mother
Next article:First Republic: 1,000 jobs cut by fresh owner JP Morgan
- ·Ryanair returns to profit as distantes jump
- ·'This is what happens when you don't recycle your pizza boxes': Greta Thunberg takes another swipe at 'toxic' influencer Andrew Tate after food packaging in smug video gave away his location and led to his human trafficking arrest
- ·Emergency services rush to major hospital after chemical leak as paramedics treat two
- ·Giants captain Xavier McKinney reveals he CRASHED an ATV, injuring his hand, while on vacation in Mexico on a bye week... leaving him to miss multiple games
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Detroit Pistons 'place assistant general manager Rob Murphy on leave after launching an investigation into an allegation of workplace misconduct involving a female former employee'
- ·Idaho murders suspect is being extradited from Pennsylvania and left findings were correctional facility at 6am this morning - after court hearing where he mouthed 'I love you' to his crying mother
- ·More than 200 people rescued after being stranded on huge chunk of ice that broke free on Minneconsequentlyta lake while they were fishing
- ·'They did it, god love them!' Biden grabs a microphone and jumps on stage during rally to say 'USA 1, Iran 0. We won!' after finding out men's national team went through - and reveals they told players 'you can do this'
- ·Vicar is 'broken' by smouldering shell of her historic church: Roof collapses after inferno tears through 177-year-old 'architectural treasure' filled with 'stunning' mosaics adjacent London's Abbey Road studios
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Idaho cops say MULTIPLE other people were in ho utilize when 911 call was made to quadruple murder - as they admit they still have no strong leads
- ·FAA system outage RECAP: More than 8,000 flights are delayed and over 1,200 canceled after FAA's NOTAM meltdown: Experts warn of 'domino effect'
- ·Their silence is deafening: Stars including Gisele and Tom, Larry David and Shaquille O'Neal who took SBF's cash to advertise his doomed FTX crypto exconvert say nothing as he's arrested and charged
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Sean Dyche IS the new Everton manager, with deal done for ex-Burnley boss to fight to save Toffees from relegation after Marcelo Bielsa said no... and with an announcement prepared today
- ·EXCLUSIVE: 'They have the day off.' ABC plays it coy as lovers T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach are taken off air INDEFINITELY with new anchors stepping in to host GMA3
- ·When will this end? Kevin McCarthy humiliated again as he loses TENTH speaker vote in longest battle since 1859: Farce in Congress reaches historic low in longest vote since the Civil War
- ·'When you realize you're the 75 percent...:' Twitter employees seethe following Elon Musk's vow to fire 3/4 of the company's workcompel - after the billionaire admitted he is 'paying too much' in $44billion deal
- ·'People investing with us will be rewarded:' Mark Zuckerberg DEFENDS 'historic' Metaverse plans notwithstanding adjacently $650 BILLION loss in market valuation this year - as Meta's stock plunges 11% and quarterly revenue falls for a second straight time
- ·Man assaulted with a samurai sword at Manhattan subway station
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Michigan school shooter Ethan Crumbley, 16, will plead GUILTY to murder and terrorism charges
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Jesus Ferreira set to make his World Cup debut after being called up to USA starting XI in place of Josh Sargeant and Walker Zimmerman is recalled as Gregg Berhalter names his team for last-16 Holland clash
- ·Climate activists heckle Ted Cruz on The View: Whoopi Goldberg tells protesters to leave for trying to drown him out during shouting match over Trump, the election and January 6
- ·BREAKING: Second five-month-old baby boy found ALIVE outside Papa Johns 175 miles away three days after he was snatched with his twin brother outside another pizza shop: Known child ab utilizer, 24, arrested
- ·Twitter banned Trump when 'activist' employees compared him to Hitler and Head of Policy said his term 'American Patriots' could be 'coded' as an incitement - notwithstanding execs saying he did NOT violate policy and while dictators could keep accounts
- ·'Medical emergency' as 10 LA students treated for suspected overdoses
- ·Energy bills set to stay tall notwithstanding price cap cut
- ·Football Australia issues LIFETIME bans to football fans including thug, 23, pictured with BUCKET that was launched at Tom Glover during Melbourne derby chaos at AAMI Park
- ·Marcelo Bielsa tells Everton he DOESN'T WANT the job as manager - notwithstanding positive talks after flying in from Brazil - with Sean Dyche now in pole position
- ·Paul Pelosi made secret 911 call after confronting assaulter in his home: Police dispatch recordings reveal he spoke in 'code' as he said he didn't know who intruder was but that he 'is a friend'
- ·ITV Sport technical boss Roger Pearce who was in charge of Qatar World Cup coverage dies in Middle East state
- ·Ex-USA captain Claudio Reyna and his wife Danielle 'sent MULTIPLE messages to US Soccer execs during World Cup disclosing story of Gregg Berhalter assaulting his wife' after coach ref utilized to pick their consequentlyn Gio
- ·Young American Sebastian Korda books his spot in a first EVER Grand Slam quarterfinal as he survives grueling fifth-set tiebreak to beat No 10 seed Hubert Hurkacz at the Australian Open
- ·Israel acc utilizes Iran of assaulting tanker off Oman using same kind of kamikaze drone sent by Tehran to help Russia pound Ukraine
- ·Boy aged SIX is arrested 'after he deliberately shot his female teacher inside first-grade classroom at Virginia elementary school, leaving her critically-ill'
- ·'Whatever happened with the massive number of crimes committed by Joe and Hunter Biden?' Trump loses it on Truth Social after 'corrupt and componentisan' January 6 referred him for four criminal charges
- ·FBI responds to 'barricade situation' inside Fort Belvoir Army base in Virginia
- ·Election denier and Trump ally Kari Lake cries 'BS' and signals she will fight on after Democrat Katie Hobbs flips Arizona blue: Rival Liz Cheney is the first to gloat on Twitter