Johnson Partygate inquiry: The key clashes to expect
Boris Johnson has set out his defence against claims he misled MPs over parties in Downing Street during lockdown.
The former prime minister has accepted that he did indeed mislead Parliament when he said the guidance and rules were followed at all times - but he insists this was not on purpose.
So the focus now turns to whether it was "inadvertent, reckless or intentional".
This will be the central issue when Mr Johnson is questioned in person by MPs on the Privileges Committee on Wednesday.
Here are some of the key arguments likely to feature in the televised grilling.
Mr Johnson will challenge the committee's pursuit of alleged "recklessness".
His legal team believes it should consider only whether he "deliberately" misled the Commons.
And he himself has suggested the concept of "recklessness" is "unprecedented and absurd".
Mr Johnson has said the committee should only be examining for accuracy his statements about compliance with Covid regulations and not the guidance.
The Commons had agreed that the committee look at his "assertions about the legality of activities in Downing Street".
So Mr Johnson argues the committee is exceeding its remit because guidance - unlike regulations - isn't legally enforceable.
This argument is likely to get short shrift from the committee.
The full resolution passed by MPs - and which set up its inquiry - specifically cites statements made by Mr Johnson, as potentially misleading.
That includes statements made on 1 December 2021, when Mr Johnson said "all guidance was followed completely in Number 10"; and on 8 December 2021, that "the guidance was followed and the rules were followed at all times".
And the committee is concerned with whether what he said was true, rather than the distinction between regulations and guidance.
A major clash is likely to occur over a large pillar of Mr Johnson's defence.
He claims he was never told that any of the gatherings at the heart of government - for which some attendees were subsequently fined - were against the rules, and that he was explicitly told some were compliant.
The committee will question why Mr Johnson relied on the advice of his then-communications chief, a political special adviser, rather than a permanent civil servant when establishing whether the 18 December 2020 "Christmas party" followed the rules.
And they will scrutinise whether that advice was ever intended to form the basis of a statement to the House rather than simply be used as a line for dealing with press inquiries.
Mr Johnson will say that a senior civil servant - his principal private secretary Martin Reynolds - also believed that rules were being complied with.
But in his evidence, he doesn't say he took Mr Reynolds's specific advice before making his now misleading statements to MPs.
(Mr Reynolds, incidentally, was the official who invited staff to "bring their own booze" to an event in the Downing Street garden in May 2020.)
And Mr Johnson says his then-parliamentary aide Andrew Griffith had been present when "multiple" Downing Street staff assured him that the 18 December party was within the rules.
The committee is likely to spend some time on whether the PM was assiduous enough in taking advice on compliance - and this may determine whether they believe he was "reckless" or not.
The committee has another line of attack - that Mr Johnson doesn't need to rely entirely on officials to know if rules were followed or flouted.
They say the evidence they have already seen "suggests breaches of the guidance would have been obvious at the time he was at the gatherings".
They refer to photographs which suggest there wasn't much social distancing at some of the No 10 events which the then-PM attended.
But Mr Johnson is expected to put up a robust defence.
Firstly, that the photos were taken by No 10's official photographer, and had rule-breaking been "obvious", it certainly wouldn't have been captured for pictorial posterity.
And secondly, that social distancing was all but impossible in warren-like Downing Street.
In his evidence, he says: "I did not believe that the guidance required full social distancing at all times."
The committee, though, might also want to explore whether alarm bells should have rung in Mr Johnson's head about an event he didn't attend.
He admits he was told that the press office gathering of December 2020 involved drink, cheese and a Secret Santa.
The committee are suggesting Mr Johnson could have told the House more about gatherings at which he was present, but he will argue that most of the controversial events only slid in to breaches of the rules when he was absent.
And he will point out that since he was issued with only one Fixed Penalty Notice, then the police must have accepted that he did not breach any rules at any other events.
So he had no knowledge of wrongdoing to divulge.
And the former occupant of No 10 will say that it is only his outspoken ex-adviser Dominic Cummings who claims he was warned about the nature of the May 2020 "garden party" - and that given Mr Cummings "animus" towards him, he is discredited as a witness.
The question is whether the committee has obtained any written evidence to back up the Cummings claims.
Even if the committee were to accept that Mr Johnson's inaccurate statements were "inadvertent" they will question him on why he did not correct the record sooner, when it became clear what he had said had been untrue, rather than await the final Sue Gray report.
The former PM will challenge the committee's assertion that he was slow to correct errors, arguing it would have been wrong to comment during a live police investigation - which concluded in May 2022, six days before he corrected the record.
There is an intriguing communication in Mr Johnson's 52 pages of evidence to the committee.
On 10 December 2021, he sent a message to his then-communications chief Jack Doyle asking "is there a way we can get the truth about this party out there".
This was a reference to the December 2020 "Christmas party", which Mr Johnson himself hadn't attended.
He says he used the word "party" as "shorthand" but the committee may suggest its use demonstrates he did have knowledge of the social, rather than work, nature of the event.
The committee also has WhatsApp messages where Mr Doyle seems to admit he is struggling to find a way of explaining why a gathering in June 2020 was within the rules and that this "blows another great gaping hole in the PM's account".
-
All five officers fired over the death of Tyre Nichols who died after a 'violent' traffic speak have been charged with second degree murder and taken into custodyBREAKING NEWS: Manchester United CONFIRM the loan signing of Wout Weghorst until the end of the seaconsequentlyn - as Red Devils pay Besiktas £2.5m to cut fleeting his spell in Turkey National Archives releases more than 13,000 classified JFK files: New details of CIA wiretaps that caught Lee Harvey Oswald calling the Soviet embassy in Mexico City two months before the assassination'When is the FBI going to the raid the White Ho utilize?': Trump leads Republican rage as he demands action after ten classified documents were found at Biden's think tank from his time as VP - when he did NOT have power to declassify documents'She was with us today:' Son of Waukesha Christmas parade victim, 79, reveals he took his mother's ashes to court as killer Darrell Brooks was found GUILTY on all 76 charges and faces life in jail Kevin McCarthy is 'forging ahead and taking a stand' after Capitol Hill chaos leaves Ho utilize with no speaker - as Dem leader Jeffries says componenty will 'not save the Republicans from their own dysfunction' and back a consensus candidateIdaho murders suspect Bryan Kohberger SMILES in court after being denied bail - as bombshell case files reveal his DNA was found on knife sheath lying next to victims' bodiesGuess who's back! Daniel Ricciardo's Formula One future is FINALLY settled as Red Bull chief confirms Australian will return to the team as their reserve driver next seaconsequentlyn after McLaren axingEpstein: Deutsche Bank to pay $75m over sexJeff Beck dies aged 78: Legendary British guitarist passes away after contracting bacterial meningitis - weeks after finishing tour with Johnny Depp
Next article:Classified documents found at former VP Mike Pence's home included briefing papers for foreign visits
- ·Brisbane confirm Chris Fagan will return to the club TODAY after coach was temporarily stood down over Hawthorn racism probe
- ·Strong 6.1-magnitude quake rattles northern Turkey and is felt as far away as Istanbul and Ankara - sparking fears of damage
- ·Elon Musk sells $4 BILLION worth of Tesla shares in third-massivgest dump since launching bid to buy Twitter for $44billion: CEO's net worth plummets to $200B
- ·If looks could kill! Twitter's 'head of cenconsequentlyrship' - who banned Trump and squashed Hunter Biden lappeak story - is pictured glaring at new boss Elon Musk hours before he FIRED her along with CEO and CFO
- ·America moves a step closer to securing its first F1 driver in EIGHT years as Logan Sargeant is given Williams seat for 2023 - if he secures the required Super License points in F2 seaconsequentlyn finale
- ·When will this end? Kevin McCarthy humiliated again as he loses TENTH speaker vote in longest battle since 1859: Farce in Congress reaches historic low in longest vote since the Civil War
- ·EXCLUSIVE: 'They have the day off.' ABC plays it coy as lovers T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach are taken off air INDEFINITELY with new anchors stepping in to host GMA3
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Chelsea co-owner Todd Boehly QUITS role as their interim sporting director and hands over to Chrispeakher Vivell and Paul Winstanley to buy three new players... after disastrous £270m summer
- ·Aston Villa announce Unai Emery as their new manager just FOUR DAYS after sacking Steven Gerrard... but caretaker Aaron Danks will remain in charge until November 1 while the Spaniard awaits his work permit
- ·Russian state TV demonstrates Brittney Griner's final days in penal colony
- ·David Crosby of Crosby, Stills & Nash dies at 81 from a 'long illness'
- ·Man, 27, held over security scare at Leeds maternity wing was arrested on suspicion of firearms and explosives offences after he was found with 'suspicious device', counter-terror police say
- ·Steve Bannon gets FOUR MONTHS in priconsequentlyn for defying January 6 subpoena: Defiant Trump adviconsequentlyr leaves court and tears into Biden's 'illegitimate regime', Nancy Pelosi and Liz Cheney - and says November 8 will be 'judgment day'
- ·Giants captain Xavier McKinney reveals he CRASHED an ATV, injuring his hand, while on vacation in Mexico on a bye week... leaving him to miss multiple games
- ·Hi-de-Hi! actor Jeffrey Holland leads tributes to co-star Ruth Madoc as she dies aged 79: Actress who played Gladys Pugh in the 1980s sitcom passes away following fall
- ·Is inflation FINALLY on the way down? Headline CPI rate dips to 10.5% as fuel costs tumble - but ministers warn giving into huge pay demands from striking public sector workers would wreck progress
- ·Minister assaults Meta boss over Facebook message encryption plan
- ·Phone pings suggest actor Julian Sands was alive after missing report
- ·Massive explosion at UK flats kills one with up to a dozen missing
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Ex-Aston Villa and Norway striker John Carew is jailed for 14 MONTHS for tax evasion after unintentionally failing to disclose income and assets abroad to Norwegian authorities
- ·Second suspect is arrested over assault on Marco Rubio canvasser 'for being Republican', after it was revealed victim is 'former' neo-Nazi
- ·'He's the unique Republican who can lose': GOP leaders, donors and even his former chief-of-staff slam Trump's decision to run in 2024 saying voters have 'rejected crazy' and it's 'time for a convert' after componenty's woeful midterms performance
- ·Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky set to visit White Ho utilize and Capitol Hill on Wednesday in first U.S. tour since Russian invasion
- ·Putin rains down 120 missiles on Ukraine in massivgest assault for weeks
- ·Top economist calls for 'lenient' migration rules
- ·BREAKING NEWS: Emotionless Parkland shooter Nikolas Cruz is sentenced to life in priconsequentlyn without parole as disgusted parents weep and beg that he's murdered behind bars
- ·Top economist calls for 'lenient' migration rules
- ·PICTURED: Boy, 12, killed after his electric scooter collided with a bus in horror crash during morning school run as 'devastated' family pay tribute
- ·DC United signs Leeds' Mateusz Klich on a two-year deal as Wayne Rooney reveals he's been keeping an eye on 'first-rate middomainer' since he helped Whites gain promotion to the Premier League
- ·'Biden was chairman of the board': Republicans claim President IS compromised by Hunter's foreign deals involving 50 nations, insist bank accounts were 'co-mingled' and White Ho utilize spent $250K to deflect damaging stories
- ·Missing Harmony Montgomery's father is charged with murder: Cops say he killed her by 'repeatedly striking her in the head with a closed fist'
- ·'New Yorkers live in fear': NY GOP candidate Lee Zeldin slams Gov. Hochul saying 'it's time to take streets back' after homeless man with TWENTY-FIVE arrests and wanted for two other sex assaults is busted for 5.30am rape of jogger in the West Village
- ·Elon Musk briefly loses title of world's affluentest man to Bernard Arnault: Tesla owner and Chief Twit's fortune falls to $185.3B from its $300B peak last year
- ·Dow Jones slumps on first trading day of the year, after Wall Street finished 2022 with its worst losses since 2008
- ·Chelsea confirm the appointment of 'world class' Laurence Stewart as their new technical director... with Todd Boehly hailing the former Monaco chief as an 'crucial' piece in their major off-pitch revamp
- ·Juventus are docked 15 POINTS by Italian court after investigation into the club's transfer dealings - as new scandal rocks the Serie A giants... and Tottenham chief Fabio Paratici is handed two-and-a-half-year BAN for his role